-
Garbo
-
-
Offline
-
New Member
-
-
Posts: 16
-
Thank you received: 19
-
-
|
Comin' atcha from my friend Publius (look it up):
Why is it that folks can't learn that what our founders said was that (in line with Hobbes, Locke, Montesquieu, etc.) we were all born free. Now, the degree to which that was a good thing was debatable depending on who you talked to, but for each the real effort was seen as how to get all these naturally free folks (with varying degrees of good/bad in each) to come together in a CIVIL society. Y'know, a social compact that we would yield some degree of our freedom to provide simple things like rule of law, democratic decision-making through representative (not popular) government, government charged with providing for civil and national defense, and for protecting individual and constitutional rights.
That's a mouthful, but doesn't even hint at all the gray that comes through 220+ years of our evolution. What is not gray is that any individual or group of citizens have the right or responsibility to take up arms against ANY democratically elected officer of OUR government. The ill-informed who think Jefferson's last word was in the Declaration of Independence with regard to taking up arms have intellect as thin as rice paper. By the early-1800's, Jefferson renounced that as one of his dumbest ideas...that elections were how to institute change in a democratic system. Even a reflective Jefferson was able to remember that this was an effort to bring democracy into effect in a physically large, diversely populated, CIVIL system of self government…an effort that until then had failed in each and every instance.
Ours is an imperfect system. We blatantly allowed the slave economies to exist and prosper for 80 years after the ink dried on our Constitution. We marched entire tribes of Indians out of territory we wanted for no other reason but greed. Hell, for a long time, the City of Boston was prohibited from hiring people of Irish descent as police officers. (Go figure...) It has taken us another 150 + years and we still have difficulty parsing out who is or is not entitled to those Constitutional protections and privileges. If nothing else, you would think that the tragedy of our Civil War would still serve as a reminder as to why taking up arms is no way to resolve conflicts.
Ours is an imperfect system. We the people have always elected a diverse set of representatives – whether in local government, states, or at the federal level. But remember, we elect them, and when we finally get pissed off enough, we can throw them out. More troublesome, perhaps, is the impact of a federal court that can have far-reaching impact without any oversight. Remember, we went more than seventy years living with the wisdom of a ruling (Plessy v. Ferguson) that rationalized that so long as treatment and facilities were equal, then separate but equal treatment under the law was OK. It was not until the 1950’s that the old thinking on the court finally realized that the idea of separate and equal is inherently unequal. Separate treatment – in schools, bathrooms, restaurants, hotels, hiring, etc. etc. etc – is unconstitutional. It is courts that finally imposed requirements that alleged felons deserved representation in court, that there were limits on search and seizure, limits on free speech, and yes, limits on gun possession. Any and all of those rulings continue to have supporters and detractors, but in each case they’ve become law of the land.
Ours is an imperfect system. We allow money in politics to receive the same or better treatment than our free speech rights and the voting franchise. Look to who has the money to invest in political campaigns and you can look to the source of many of our problems (…and in my humble opinion this is not a partisan distinction!) I am not so crass to think money corrupts the politicians, but the money chases people with like interests. (By the way, that observation is supported by research: Please check it out if you wish.) Given how that warps the policy discussions, it’s not surprising Americans look for someone to blame. Once again, we need to look in the mirror. If you’re pissed about money in politics, write your representatives. Join like-minded groups to change how that works. Sitting on your ass and blaming everyone else for being corrupt may make you feel good, but accomplishes nothing.
We are an imperfect people. We express this in fits of violence, ignorance, bigotry, and invective. We get pissed, we look for someone to blame. Presidents are pretty used to it. Bush II took his lumps as an intellectual lightweight and political dilettante. History will no doubt suggest he’s somewhere between the extremes. But, even with that dislike, Bush was never subjected to the vilification and outright misrepresentations our current president has seen. Birthers? Really, c’mon. You can do better than that. By what fount of logic can any mother foresee their kid’s greatness to attempt to hide their kids birthplace. Obama as anything but a practicing Christian. Sorry guys, unless I’m reading conspiracy literature, this is totally off balance. The Kenyan connection. A pretty blatant vote grabbing tactic in any era. I am sure that somewhere you can find a source that will describe his Mother with horns and a tail. Attack the guy’s ideas, great. Attack the guy’s policies, great. Suggest unsupported allegations that at this point are pointless at best, then something else is at work. (I would by the way, caution against those who plan to use Canadian birth of Texas Senator Ted Cruz as a campaign attack tactic should he plan to run in 2016. Remember, attack ideas, policies! Or perhaps we should suggest he is an agent of Mexico City.)
I'm pretty sure Obama has become this lightening rod for multiple reasons, but the intensity of it suggests the death throes of a particular political/social culture. There is a hard core, die-hard element of our population that continues to hold to values/ideas that have eroded ever since the New Deal. The notion that government has some responsibility for the public welfare was and continues to be a big shocker for many. Then, "Oh My God", we have the Voting Rights Act, Civil Rights, the extension of Constitutional rights and protections to women and gays, and finally...God forbid... the notion that Americans dying in the streets without access to healthcare is unacceptable...
Again, I find this is gross confusion of our reason for being the democracy we are. The American dream is about liberty, yes. But it is just as importantly about living together with mutual respect in a civil society. Our political system was built to make decisions for millions of Americans and all the diversity that represents. We have always had a multitude of positions on what’s right/wrong/legal/illegal. And as votes solidify around those positions, the political system has ALWAYS come around to those same positions. When you are on the losing side of the equation, it’s hard to remember that a majority of American voters apparently disagree with you. Remember: votes count. There are always winners and losers, but we get better representatives, better policies, when our elected representatives get clearer signals from the voting public. If you disagree, then make your voice and your vote heard. You may still lose, but maybe it won’t drive you quite as nuts. It is perhaps most difficult when we hold positions with absolute certainty. Hate to bust your bubble, but for the most part that only happens in Churches, Mosques, or Synagogues. Democratic process requires a compromise on almost everything: speech; religion; taxation; privacy; economics; welfare; healthcare; food safety; you name it. We have NEVER been an absolute anything – not an absolute free market; not an absolute Christian nation; not an absolute welfare state; nada, zip, bupkus. Our policies reflect democratic attempts to address issues in degrees. When you can only accept positions that are absolute, you are bound to be frustrated by our political results.
So, we can continue with the inflammatory language, the scare tactics about big government dictating your healthcare, undermining our moral fibre, or taking away your guns. They can wave flags, wear funny hats and costumes, be openly hostile, or gin up false accusations that supposedly justify disrespect for the highest office in the land. But, while it may take awhile, Americans usually do finally come around on the big subjects. When my father was born, the notion of civil rights was unthinkable in real world terms. The idea of access to healthcare as a right of citizenship??? OMG! Don't get me wrong: We still have our race problems. We still argue over access to polls. We still harbor antipathy toward gays and the poor. But just think back 40 years or so, and look where we've come. And, shocker, an African-American president...holy shit! Yes, sooner or later, voters will elect enough folks to office that we may even have some common-sense gun control that seriously limits defective human beings from walking into public schools and freely opening fire on children... or movie theaters, or political talking events. We can be stupid, but hopefully history will show we're not totally ignorant.
For those ready to paint me into some corner they find easy to understand, let me assure you, I am a fiscal conservative and a social liberal. By some definitions that makes me a Libertarian, but I wouldn’t want to disappoint them. Unlike pure libertarians, I support a role for government in addressing issues defined by our democratic processes. I am as patriotic as they come, and with good reason. I know what alternative systems have to offer, and they pale by comparison. I have helped to balance public budgets and worked to limit taxation. I have voted Republican, Independent, and Democratic. I was a real Reagan Republican from the 1970’s through the 1980’s, and am disgusted by the pretenders of today. I support the rule of law and our efforts to promote a civil society. I hate paying taxes, but I understand that if I want clean water, good roads, better schools, safe food, and/or the protections of police, fire, or military organizations, I better shell out. In my lifetime I have been a hunter and black powder enthusiast. I support the Constitutional and legal protections that prevent government abuse of our Civil Liberties and Civil Rights. And, I support our democratic institutions. In the end, it is an extension of my respect for any and all citizens who choose to take ownership of our government, our representatives, and our policies and laws.
Folks, knee-jerk politics and ideology is real easy. Life is so much simpler when all you do is accept some particular dogma as the path to political nirvana (left or right, by the way) If you want to understand how the system really impacts you, question, research, compare. Facts and data are a hell of a lot better paths to understanding than Fox News or MSNBC. The talking heads have their own views and they love it when you unquestioningly buy into their version of accepted wisdom. Sure, life’s more complicated when you question accepted wisdom, but the rewards are incrementally greater. You might just start to feel like you’ve got some control over your own life.
That’s my piece. I doubt if it will disrupt the echo chamber, but it’s my attempt at reasonable discussion. I hope you find that for the most part it lacks invective, might include some germ of rational thought, is fundamentally sound in its interpretation of history and political theory, and just maybe helps you feel a bit better about this American system of self-governance we all love to beat on every once in a while. It is imperfect in an imperfect world. Often it is misinformed, misguided, mistaken. More often than not it means well, it strives to be better, it can reflect our better angels. And, it is ours, collectively. You may or may not agree with me, but my vote counts as much as yours and vice versa. The only time when that's not the case is when you don't show up at the polls. When we agree that majority rules, we better learn to get over it when we’re on the losing side of the issue. And trust me, I’ve lost more than I’ve won.
Publius
(Apologies to James Madison, but I can think of no more deserving author to emulate. If you really want to get into this, read The Federalist Papers, Common Sense, The Declaration of Independence, The Constitution of the United States. Better to get a real handle on what our founding fathers really thought and did than rely on some present-day “face” on TV that wants to shift polls in some preferred direction.)
The following user(s) said Thank You: MaD!, Big Tex, Hyperdrive
|