McFate wrote: I'd like to hear a real answer here from a Christian conservative. I'm asking in all sincerity.
How does a Christian reconcile with fiscal conservatism?
Wow, this thread has digressed.
Anyway, as a pastor (edit: and mostly a conservative), I'll explain where I come out on this. I think the place to start is that no political system is perfect. Not one. They all have their strengths and weaknesses. As an American, I think this includes, democracy (including the Constitution and Declaration of Independence) Excellent ideals as they are, they ain't perfect.
This most definitely pertains to the socialism vs conservatism argument. As, when taken to extremes both are horribly wrong. I think the answer is to humbly accept each others strengths and accept your own weaknesses. To try to find a balance between the two philosophies is the answer, but in reality practically impossible. Doesn't mean we quit trying.
Regarding balance, here's an example:
- Love without justice: enables sin and removes all healthy boundaries and creates license (anything goes). (something that democrats and socialist are accused of)
- Justice without love: is abusive manipulation and cares nothing of a person's welfare or why a person may be in the state they are; this creates legalism.(something that republicans and conservatives are accused of)
I see, that God holds these both in perfect tension. But with humanity. No way.
I lived among Native Americans in Northern Ontario for 3 years. The social problems that they face are off the map. For instance studies, have found that 60 to 70% of the people there have experienced sexual abuse (the percentage actually gets higher the further north you go). And the community/reserve that I lived close to, has experienced wave upon wave of youth suicides. One year I was there, out of a community of 2000 people 20-30 took their own lives and the number of unsuccessful attempts would a have been triple that!
Clearly huge issues, and one's that have happened, for a myriad of reasons. No silver bullet for it. But, due to a century old treaty provision these people had all they needed materially. There were given: homes, satellite TV (flat screens, which were brand new then), brand new 4x4 trucks and snowmobiles. Money for food, etc. Everything given, but one thing: purpose. A purpose for life; a reason to live, to get up each day.
I think Jimmy Carter and Habitat for Humanity have struck a good balance though. Their ideal of sweat equity creates accountability, boundaries, and purpose. And it gives the hopeless: hope, a leg up, and way out. Why, more governments don't adopt these ideals is beyond me. Probably, easier to just throw money at problems than to take the time to relate to people, in order to implement this idea. For the record, I voted against Carter, but I was ignorant

Yeah I'm giving away my age now...
I think your last question was: why don't Christians do what the Bible says? (or something like that)
That, is also an excellent question and one that, in my mind, can only be explained in the same way as imperfect political systems. In other words, both are the result of living in broken and fallen world.
But, it's not for a lack of being told to listen and obey God's words. Listen to Jesus' half-brother James From the book of his name chapter 1, verse 22-25.
"Do not merely listen to the word, and so deceive yourselves. Do what it says. Anyone who listens to the word but does not do what it says is like someone who looks at his face in a mirror and, after looking at himself, goes away and immediately forgets what he looks like. But whoever looks intently into the perfect law that gives freedom, and continues in it—not forgetting what they have heard, but doing it—they will be blessed in what they do."
I guess the answer is: on a regular basis, to humbly ask ourselves, are living by His word? And, ask His forgiveness when we don't. Rejecting the temptation to fatalism, and believing this: that if God says, that we should do something; then it must be achievable
and He must be willing to supply strength and ability to do it. All, He needs is a willing heart. The question to the Church and to humanity is: are we willing?