[DD]Big C wrote: Objective presentation of facts:
I encourage you to fact check this and confirm it. (Mostly FBI and UN stats)
Sorry, doesn't stack up as an objective presentation of the facts. More like highly subjective and selective presentation of some facts.
The first slide says up front that there are 31,672 gun incidents in America each year, correctly distinguishing between crime, accident, suicide and self-defense. Fine, but there are still 31,672 gun incidents each year. Oh just a moment, let’s check. No, there are not 31,672 incidents per year in America – there are 31,672 gun deaths per year. A minor point perhaps, but it has bearing on the deduction that “every year, guns are used over 80 x more often to protect a life than to take one.” Does anyone feel a bit uncomfortable with that logic?
Gun ownership vs intentional homicide rate is a favorite NRA statistic. Yes, the USA has probably the highest ownership rate on earth but not the highest gun homicide rate. That is undeniable, but let’s examine the competition. It depends the data you use, but the USA is probably number 12 or 13 in the world in terms of gun homicides, behind nations like:
Colombia
El Salvador
Guatemala
Honduras
Jamaica
Panama
Mexico
Swaziland
South Africa
Uruguay
Venezuela
Seriously, do these South American and African leaders in gun carnage give the USA an acceptable benchmark for success?
Oh, wait up, we do have a European comparison on slide 3. Apparently the UK, where guns are banned, is over four times more violent than the USA with 2,340 violent crimes per 100,000 people compared to 466 violent crimes per 100,000 people in the USA. Yes, the statistics are correct, but the deduction is absurd.
The legal definitions of violent crime need to be understood before you swallow this one.
The FBI only classifies four types of crime as “violent crime”: murder and non-negligent manslaughter, forcible rape, robbery, and aggravated assault. The British definition includes all “crimes against the person,” including simple affrays and assaults, all robberies, and all sexual offenses.
Europe has had three of the worst six school shootings. True, I think? But I could find data to show that the USA has had seven of the worst ten school shootings.
Feel free to unpick my analysis, but my point is not to be 100% correct. It is to ask you to be a bit more questioning of the NRA propaganda that’s out there.