I'm rather late for the Zuperman bashing but I'm not here to defend him, nor am I here to sing praises. As most of you who know me, I'm not the type who complains much and would rather hunker down and face things head-on. Just thought of sharing some of my thoughts.
Last night, I decided to visit Storm Raiders, a WW2 air combat game, the game that I left behind for Dogfight. While Dogfight is nowhere near perfect, I have a number of things to be thankful for. And after my brief re-appearance in Storm Raiders, I suddenly remembered why I ultimately migrated to Dogfight.
1) Level playing field
Yes, higher ranking players and planes will always have the upper hand. But think about this: in Storm Raiders, there is currently a "domination" of players using the MAC over the ones using mobile devices: the Mac players fly like UFOs i.e. Mac Player in a Mosquito handily OUT-TURNS a Zero in a SLOW-SPEED turn fight. Energy tactics? Boom and zoom? Its an arcade flight game that focus on T&B and has little in the way of tactics. Should energy tactics or B&Z work, you'd get frowned upon by the game's so-called aces. At least in DF, the lowest level plane can win with the right tactics, regardless of device. And speaking of frowned upon;
2) The community
If DF's world chat is a cesspool, imagine having some players taunt you everytime you get shot down with lines like:
"Haha asshole/loser/other expletives"
"god what a rookie"
"2v2 kings! Pussies!"
"Smart playing???? WEAK!"
These are just samples and are some of the lightest. Imagine seeing worse kinds of lines spammed a lot in the middle of a game. And to top it off, some of the aces in that game are so full of themselves that they think they are gods and should therefore be assholes to other players. Come to to think of it, many of the verbal offenders in world chat share similar characteristics to the trolls in Storm Raiders. At least we get to police ourselves here in DF. And many will come to your aid if they can. For all the drama seen here, it's still relatively light compared to the issues that I see showing up at the other game that I used to play. And last but not the least;
3) Lag
Storm Raiders has some of the worst lags in my experience. Imagine having this "rubber bullet" effect wherein your target is in front of you, you've been peppering it with bullets since forever and it still doesn't go down. Meanwhile, your target is already on your six and you're surprised that your plane with 98% strength is already down to 5% in a few seconds without you even knowing it. At least in DF, there are a lot of warnings to know if you're lagging long before you get into a furball and when you do, you're not always on the losing end. You always have a fighting chance regardless of rank. And when its too much, you can always choose the server closest to your location to lessen the lag.
I'm not saying Storm Raiders is the worst game out there. In fact, its quite good. As for Dogfight and its corresponding issues, for those who paid, they have every right to complain, its just that, a guy has other things to attend to as well and for all we know, he's attending to those issues quietly. And with the above-mentioned reasons that I've experienced, I say lets focus on the good while waiting for feedback from Zup. That aside, I'm very happy with Dogfight. I get a flight game that doesn't lag much, where technical advantages can be overcome with teamwork and tactics (and not be frowned upon everytime!) and have a very decent community of enthusiasts to boot.
Just my two cents.
Cheers everyone.