Hi, I'd just like to share a little something that I've learned the hard way... In no way am I professing to be an expert... again, I'm just sharing something that I learned the hard way...
I've noticed that when aircraft engage in a game of scissors (flat, rolling or vertical) the slower aircraft tends to come out more victorious due to the overshoot-enticing nature of the tactic...
As per wikipedia, (not the best source but good enough a starting source as any), here is the definition of a scissors:
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scissors
"The Scissors is an aerial dog fighting maneuver, commonly used by military fighter pilots before the advent of high thrust-to-weight fighters (which allow for extended maneuvering in the vertical plane) in the late 1950s to mid-1960s and later, and before the perfection of the all-aspect air-to-air missile, and reliable BVR (beyond-visual-range) weapons. Thus, although still taught as a basic fighter maneuver useful in a guns-only or short-range missile encounter, the scissors were most commonly encountered by pilots in aerial combat during World War II and the Korean War, and much less frequently since. In fact, for many years now fighter pilots flying aircraft with even a reasonable thrust-to-weight ratio and average wing loading are well advised to avoid engaging in a scissors maneuver, since any turning, rolling or slow-speed disadvantage the pilot's aircraft might have with respect to his opponent (or pilot skill in energy assessment and management techniques) will quickly become evident in the scissors, and lead to his defeat in short order.
Basic Fighter Maneuvering theory recognizes two different types of scissors maneuvers; the flat scissors and the rolling scissors."
Using a Fokker E.III (monoplane), Spad XIII or the Red Baron Triplane, I was able to bring down a number of players who were using Level5 aircraft using this tactic. Of course, I still get my tailplane handed to me on a silver platter mostly on part of the more experienced pilots who I fly against in these top-tier aircraft. Of the ones I was able to shoot down? I gather they are mostly pilots who bought their Lvl5 planes (nothing wrong with that) and has roughly the same level of experience as I do.
What's my point here? It means that newcomers in their Lvl 1-2 planes have a chance to win in a maneuvering fight with the top-tiers. Of course, the odds will be more or less on the side of the more experienced player with a top-tier plane but at the very least, they have a fighting chance. And Dogfight is one of those "light combat simulators" that allows the player to at least engage in a form of scissors.
Yes, I'm putting my KDR on the line here by sharing a tactic that has helped me become successful to a degree, but who knows? I might be able to help an aspirant or two.