Hi Y'all.. I get asked this in World Chat quite a lot so I thought I would start a thread about it. Newer & even more experienced players ask about this plane or that one & "should I get this one or save up for that one?"
So this is my take on each of the different planes in Dogfight.. their strengths & weaknesses & characteristics. These are MY opinions only & DO include each plane being fully upgraded! Feel free to chime in if you have different opinions to mine as this info can only help people to make informed plane buying choices (wish I had been more informed before I bought my first plane!)
Free Planes - there are THREE of them!
1. Airco DH2 - the plane you pilot in the practice missions. Many people look down on this plane but it has a couple of things going for it.. it is difficult to hit because of the empty space behind the prop & it turns well. In capable hands it can shoot other planes down because of its maneuverability & since it's slow, faster planes if they miss it often fly right in front of you so you can blast them! When carrying a bomb though, it can barely fly lol!
2. Fokker Dr.I - The first of the two tri-planes.. very capable plane as in it maneuvers very well although it's slow. Able to bring down the Airco more times than not.. as well as being able to bring down the one tier up Fokker tri-plane Red Baron plane due to this maneuverability! (but that only happens in the dogfight mission)
3. Albatros D.V.a - The zebra striped M.O.R.A.F plane.. you get it for free
I am told (*edit: as I know now) when you make MORAF. It's a Albatros D.V. with a black & white striped paint job as flown by Bruno Loerzer in WWI. Does it have any advantages over the standard D.V. besides it being piloted by a VERY experienced player? I do know that the way it turns I [THOUGHT] it got an additional star in the maneuver category but now that I am a moraf I know that it doesn't.. yet it's TOUGH to shoot down lol!
Tier 2 Planes
1. Red Baron - aka Redbaron (2-guns) - aka the flying Red Brick - aka pretty Red Target - grrr! Many of you know this plane is my pet peeve.. the first plane I ever bought with earned coins.. I HATE IT! Carrys a lot of ammo though.. so good for shooting zeppelins & in head to head shooting going across the Valley of Death - but other than that it's just a flying target for experienced (& inexperienced pilots) to bring down. Can't turn for poop despite its speed advantage over the free planes & the Nieuport XI in the same tier can shoot it down 2 out of 3 times in a dogfight.. ESPECIALLY once both planes have passed each other and it becomes a turning battle. I would give mine away if I could to a new player except I wouldn't want to handicap one.. it's pretty red & 2 guns & added speed & ammo draws the unwary into purchasing it.. grrrr! Big Mistake! I would choose the free Fokker over this or DEFINATELY the Nieuport that is in the same tier.
2. Nieuport XI - my first 'favorite' plane. Despite being shot down TONS in the Red Baron I finally earned some more coins and got this plane & quickly upgraded it.. then I FINALLY had something that could compete, even if on a limited basis. This plane can shoot down the free planes (although the free Fokker does give it a run for it's money!) & can take down the Red Baron plane 2 out of every 3 goes. Flying with a bomb on it sucks, but hey, you do what you gotta do. For me in bombing missions I was often sneaky in it.. going high or around or whatever it took to help my team win that mission. This plane earned me the coins to buy my Spad as well as got me a little known as people would say "Where's Zebra?" & somebody else would say, "Look Up!" lol!
Tier 3 Planes
1. Spad S.XIII (2 guns) - Best bang for the buck in Dogfight! This plane can shoot down ANY plane in the air in capable hands.. it's fast enough (when not carrying a bomb lol!) and highly maneuverable and it is the cream of the crop in Tier 1-4 planes.. yes, you heard that right, I like it better than either of the 2 planes in the tier above it! I LOVE my Spad!

a
Zebra approved
BEST BUY
2. Fokker E.III - aka german mono-winged plane - the only mono-winged plane in Dogfight it's low profile makes it more difficult to hit which is it's primary strength. Slightly less maneuverable than the Spad yet in head on shooting or trying to shoot it while you are on its six, it takes better aim or more ammo to bring one down. [*edit-despite it's 2 star speed rating it is actually a little faster than the other 2 star planes, probably due to its lesser weight without that second wing & struts] If you go head to head with it you better be a good shot!
Tier 4 Planes
1. Albatross D.III - fine plane with good maneuverability & speed & carries plenty of ammo.. great for most all missions.. it works well! Although WAY more expensive than the Spad I give the edge to the Spad over both this plane & the other plane in this fourth tier, the Nieport XVII, yet this plane CAN & DOES shoot down all planes in Dogfight in capable hands.
2. Nieport XVII - aka the Ferrari plane (the prancing stallion/horse symbol on this plane flown by Francesco Baracca actually DID become the symbol of Ferrari after being presented to Enzo Ferrari by Baracca's mother.) Good handling plane that carries plenty of ammo.. I rate it TIED with the other plane in Tier 4, the D.III (Actually some may argue differently, so as I don't own it I can't truly say, my experiences come from shooting 'em down in that case) Anyone who has one can feel free to give us their impressions. (*edit: in retrospect I rank this tied with the Spad.. it is fast and handles great in a turning battle)
Tier 5 Planes
1. SE5a - the allieds top tier plane. Now that I have one & flown it quite a bit if there's one thing to say about this plane is that it is smooth! It handles well but flies differently then other the other top planes.. & it is tough to shoot down as I have seen from the other perspective.. and dives FAST! When carrying a bomb it's nearly on par with tier 3 planes WITHOUT bombs loL! But it does seem to be a little slower turning than the D.V. when bombless.
2. Albatros D.V. - german top tier plane. Fast.. maneuverable.. plenty of ammo.. what's not to like? Oh! the purple (or lilac) paint.. lol. Like who really sees purple/lilac as a camouflage color?!? In shooting it down I give this plane the edge over the SE5a.. seems harder to kill in a turning battle than the SE5a [*edit-I own one now & it's FAST!]
3. Albatros D.V.a - MORAF zebra striped plane - yes, I know I already spoke of it earlier, but it deserves additional mention due to the fact you have to EARN it! I will hopefully earn one someday.. & be a Zebra in a zebra!

(*edit: I got one of my own now!

)
Speed Chart
with bomb / without bomb
2 Stars = 120/150 [ Airco DH2 / Fokker Dr.I / Nieuport XI ]
2 Stars = 115/155 [*Fokker E.III (Eindecker mono-wing) ]
3 Stars = 125/160 [Spad S.XIII / Red Baron / Albatros D.III / Nieport XVII ]
4 Stars = 130/165 [Albatros D.V. / SE5a / Albatros D.V.a ]
Upgrading Planes
To upgrade a plane is to turn each silver star to gold. The cost for each of these upgrades is 1/2 the cost of the plane! For EACH UPGRADED STAR!
*Tip - Always upgrade SPEED FIRST! Armament is merely the number of bullets you are carrying onboard. But all the bullets in the world won't help you if you are shot down because you are too slow!!
Do your opinions on these planes differ from mine? Well if so, then speak up! =)
Here is a good website listing the planes of WWI in order of top speed..
WWI aircraft ranked by speed
Z