Hamers wrote: Gm payed back their money years ahead of schedual. If gm had fell then the whole auto industry,whitch michigan is dependant on, wohld have fell. By saving gm he saved michigan.
Hamers, let's say you dig out $100 of your own money so I can start a lemonade stand. I say, "Great, let's call $10 of it a loan, due in 2 years. I expect to make $180 in profits over the next 5 years ($36 per year), so let's call the other $90 a purchase of half of my lemonade stand's profits, so in 5 years you'll make the $90 all back." Then I make the stand and start selling lemonade, but I'm only making $12 per year in profits instead of the expected $36. In the first year, I repay the $10 that we called a loan.
I now tell all our friends that I've "repaid your loan" in full! Ahead of time!
Now, you're not really out $90. The lemonade stand is making some money, but it's not worth the $90 you paid for half the profits. It's worth about $45. And maybe it'll do better, but there are other kids' lemonade stands that are kicking my butt. Plus, I'm out there dancing in the streets telling our friends that I've paid off your loan to me in full, 1 year ahead of time.
Tell me, did I represent what happened accurately by saying that I've repaid "the loan" in full?
Here are the facts on GM, and if anyone has different information, please challenge this:
- US$67 Billion of government (taxpayer funded) money was used in the GM bailout alone.
- $1.0B of that was loaned to the pre-bankruptcy GM company, just like a bank lending to a company, except that the government was the bank. $136M has been paid back to the Treasury, leaving $864M unrecovered.
- $6.7B of that was loaned to the post-bankruptcy GM company. That entire amount, plus the interest owed, has been repaid in 2010, five years ahead of schedule.
- The rest (about $59B) was used to purchase GM and GMAC (a financing subsidiary) stock, and then the cash from the stock purchase went to fund operating costs for the company and subsidiaries. That stock is worth about $21B today, leaving $38B in taxpayer funds that have not been recovered.
My beef is that when a politician says "GM repaid its loans," there's a word game being played. The politicians are trying to make it sound like all of the money that went into the bailout has come back to the Treasury, at zero net cost to taxpayers in the end. Just like when I told all our friends that I had repaid your loan to me to start the lemonade stand. The exact words were true, but what the words implied was false.
I just want people here to question when they hear stuff from Republicans, Democrats, any politicians, and the media. Go get the facts, THEN form opinions. Politicians (and the news media, and certainly non-news TV and newspapers) use these word games ALL THE TIME. Why do you think I set up that $10 as a "loan", and why do you think the government set up the $6.7B as a loan? So they could later say that the "loan" was repaid, without admitting that there was still $38B that was outstanding. They really do this, as awful as it sounds. All politicians.
Manfred